Report a Claim Below you will find a list of insurance companies. Click on their name, and it will take you directly to the carriers page on filing a claim. For the few that don't have links, we've included a phone number where you can call the insurance company to file your claim. Aegis - 800-233-2160 First Chicago Hanover Fire & Casualty Safeco American Modern Flood Risk Solutions Hartford State Auto ASI Foremost Hastings Mutual Steadily BHHC Foremost Signature Homeowners of America Tower Hill Branch Founders Lemonade - go to the app Travelers Bristol West Goodville Mutual National General Trexis Celina Grange Nationwide Universal North America Chubb Grinnell NSI: West Bend 877-922-5246 Universal Property & Casualty Clearcover Guard Openly USLI Commonwealth Hagerty Philadelphia Utica National Donegal Hanover Progressive Wayne Encompass